
I have to say that the issues raised by my JJP colleague Marcus Touissaint in his recent post about Michigan wannabe Senator So Bad Pete Hoekstra raised one hell of a good point, namely who is the woman who agreed to do this ad and why did she agree to do it?
Well, now we know a little bit more, although we still don't know the actual identity of the mystery woman in the ad. Still, this story is getting better. According to this recent piece in TPMLiveWire, the Asian American woman in Hoekstra's quite obviously racist political ad that he ran during the Superbowl as part of his campaign effort to bring down Democratic Sen. Debbie Stabenow, has stirred up some serious anger from at least one Asian American Republican elected official in Michigan by the name of Alicia Ping. As it turns out, Ms. Ping is a Republican Washtenaw County Commissioner and had apparently been "leaning toward" supporting Hoekstra's until she saw that ad. Now she's so upset that not only is she withdrawing her support of Hoekstra but she's considering giving that support to some unknown challenger in the Republican primary who is given little chance of winning. And to be quite honest, I seriously doubt a racist Republican ad will hurt Hoekstra among Michigan Republicans, and Asians aren't exactly a majority in this state.
But once Hoekstra gets past the primary is where things are likely to change, especially going up against Stabenow, whom many Republicans have tried and failed to bring down before mistaking her for an easy mark.
From TPM Live Wire:
According to Ping, Hoekstra is about to be in a world of controversy thanks to his decision to stand by the ad, despite the widespread outrage. She told me that leaders from across the minority populations of Michigan will jointly condemn Hoekstra in an open letter tomorrow, guaranteeing that the negative press surrounding the ad — and his response to it — will be back on TV for another day at least.
It’s possible that Hoekstra, trying to avoid the embarrassing defeat he suffered in 2010’s gubernatorial primary, welcomes the attention on the assumption that cries of racial intolerance from the left will help him court conservative primary voters in the Senate race.
But Ping makes it clear that the ad’s negative effects cut across party lines. In our conversation, she outlined just how hurtful Hokestra’s ad — with its depiction of a Chinese woman speaking broken English — is to Americans of Asian descent.
“You know when we were growing up they used to have that show Sha Na Na,” Ping said. “On the show was a guy named Bowsewr and I remember they used to have these skits [depicting Asians] and I would say to my mother, ‘why do they do that?’ And she would say, ‘Well, it’s supposed to be funny because they’re making fun of the Asian-Americans.’ And I just looked at her and I didn’t understand it because my grandparents were working so hard to get their citizenship and learn the language. And it’s really hard to learn the English language, and it’s really hard to go the other way, too.”
“So when you lived through this, growing up in the American culture and have somebody so easily make fun of it, it’s just painful because these people are working really hard to try to achieve the American dream,” Ping continued. “And to so blatantly be able to cast it off isn’t acceptable.”
None of which quite offers a satisfactory answer to Brother Touissaint's question of why, exactly, did the Mystery Asian Ad lady agree to do this? Did she think that it was some sort of a gag? Was she not told that this was going to be for a political advertisement supporting a Republican candidate who obviously cares little or nothing about offending Asian people? Is it that she can't speak English so she didn't know what she was saying? But then just because she doesn't speak English (if that's the case) hardly equates to her being stupid, which she would have to be to agree to do a television ad in a language she doesn't understand endorsing someone she may hardly know.
But chances are she speaks English just fine. Matter of fact I'm gonna go out on a limb and say I bet she probably speaks better English than I do, especially when she went to the bank to deposit that check. And she certainly doesn't seem to mind lending her smiling face to Hoekstra's campaign website, debbiespenditnow.com. Yep, Hoekstra thinks racism is such a marketable commodity he has chosen to make it a selling point in his campaign. Racism, according to Hoekstra, is good for the Michigan economy. Others apparently disagree...
From the Detroit News:
A chorus of ethnic, religious and cultural groups called on Hoekstra to pull the ad that's slated to run for two weeks in Michigan. Democrats (as well as some Republicans) blasted the GOP candidate for advancing stereotypes by using a Chinese-American actress speaking in broken English.
Politicos questioned how the GOP frontrunner would neutralize the spot some say "backfired."
"The message he wished to get out has gotten lost in the discussion," said Grand Valley State University political science professor Erika King. "I'm sure it's not what the campaign expected would happen."
King said it's too early in the campaign to know what kind of impact the ad will have politically. It depends, she said, on whether he can neutralize the fallout and how the opposition uses it.
There was one immediate effect. Washtenaw County Commissioner Alicia Ping on Monday was so offended by the ad she donated money to Hoekstra opponent Clark Durant's campaign.
"For him not to know that this is unacceptable, either he doesn't care or he doesn't get it," said the Saline Republican, who is Chinese-American.
On Monday, Hoekstra stood by the $144,000 statewide ad buy, blaming the "left" for bringing up racial concerns to divert the conversation from the real issue he was pushing of Democratic incumbent Sen. Debbie Stabenow's spending record.
Maybe Pete might want to consider renaming his really cool racist campaign site "PetieLoseItNow.com"